13 Comments
User's avatar
Aleksandar's avatar

There is another way to play and it is my favorite - PBtA way (Ironsworn).

Just roll 2 sets of dice. if both are success - it is full succes.

if only one - success with a price that moves story forward.

Both misses - total failure.

for me it is the only way to play.

Expand full comment
Croaker's avatar

A reader after my own heart. The ironsworn system is so elegant and would work perfectly in this situation.

Do you use that for combat also?

Expand full comment
Eric Dill's avatar

I'd love more details on how you use it, and second Croaker's question about combat. I cut my teeth on Ironsworn and it will always be my favorite TTRPG (solo or otherwise), but I crave a bit more complex combat (and inventory/wealth system).

Expand full comment
Grim Sour Games's avatar

Same! I don't trust myself to set difficulty ratings or I'll go too easy 🤣

Expand full comment
Heavy Cavalry's avatar

this was a great read, solo rpgs from the start to present, i found it very interesting. thanks

Expand full comment
Croaker's avatar

Thanks for reading! A lot of people think solo RPGs are somehow new but they've been making them and writing about them since the very start of the hobby.

Expand full comment
Nicola Santagostino's avatar

Thanks for the support!

Expand full comment
Croaker's avatar

Keep up the cool work!

Expand full comment
Randall Hayes's avatar

I am posting my first solo experiment on Monday.

Can't believe it took me this long to take the plunge.

Expand full comment
Croaker's avatar

So great to hear! Have a great time creating and posting it.

Expand full comment
Aleksandar's avatar

Honestly, I have not played 5th edition few years now. Sold my books as I prefer other systems. I am more storyteller than tactical combat type. But based on tbe other old school games I play I would say yes, in combat too. like full hit would be advantage for hero, weak hit dissadvantage for hero, etc..

Expand full comment
Eric Dill's avatar

I don't play much 5e either. I like the idea of using the strong hit/weak hit as advantage/DisAdv

Expand full comment
Eric Dill's avatar

Elminster's is such a good suggestion! It was the first 5e specific emulator I tried and, in my opinion, was much easier to use with 5e than Mythic (and I love Mythic). I have several chapters/sessions of a solo 5e game using Elminster's that I really should finish and post. The Solo Adventurer's Toolbox is also a really good one, though quite a bit more expensive.

Also, I really need to play Cargoth. Its maybe my favorite thing you've made so far, and I've not even looked at the new edition!

Expand full comment